Today we’ll discuss Magical Girl Raising Project volume 1. Lots of spoilers in this post!
Overall I thought this was one of those stories that knows exactly what it wants to do, and goes straight for it. Nothing ground-breaking, but a fun read. (Well, fun if you like death game thrillers.) I found the large cast of characters surprisingly memorable though, and I enjoyed just how over-the-top everything played out.
I mean, we got scenes like the one where a ninja and a witch fight a cowgirl armed with magical Soviet weaponry. And we had characters named Cranberry, Swim Swim, Winterprison, and Hardgore Alice. So if nothing else, I was at least entertained. And really, half the fun in these Battle Royale type stories is reading the imaginative ways the characters manage to kill each other, right? I felt Raising Project delivered on that front.
I’m curious to hear everyone’s thoughts on this one. I know there was an anime adaptation of this story almost a year ago, but I never noticed many people talking about it. It makes me wonder if this light novel was picked up because it was actually more popular than I thought it was? Either way though, I’m glad it was licensed, because it’s quite different from anything else Yen Press has at the moment.
Which characters were your favorites? I recall during the first act of the story, feeling upset when my favorites were unceremoniously killed off. But it turned out that almost everyone was set to die in this one. Hopefully you didn’t get too attached to any of them! Anyways, my favorite was Ruler. I could empathize with her ambitions, ha ha.
What did you think of the mascot character Fav? At first I couldn’t help but think of him as a combination of Kyubey (Madoka Magica) and Monokuma (Dangan Ronpa), and it seems I wasn’t the only one who thought that. But in the end, I got the impression that Fav is much less ambitious or invested in his work, and is simply going along with Cranberry’s killing game scenarios for the sake of entertainment. (So, he’s not so different from us readers, you could say?) If anything, I’d compare Fav more to Death Note‘s Ryuk, the death god who enables the protagonist to kill all the people he wants, simply because he’s bored.
Speaking of wanting to kill people, what did you think of Cranberry’s plan overall? The story proved time and again that under the right circumstances, a comparatively weak character could kill off a strong one–and that was something Cranberry would experience firsthand in the end. I’m not certain if it’s right to simply call her insane, but I did appreciate getting some backstory for her that explained how her experience in becoming a magical girl was more or less a killing game just by unlucky chance.
Lastly, how did you feel about the ending of this story? I was a bit surprised by how dark the story became in the final act, and I’m not sure how hopeful I’d call the conclusion. In the end, Snow White wasn’t able to save any of the other magical girls. Meanwhile Ripple still went through with her revenge against Swim, and only survived through her own determination. Snow White and Ripple didn’t become friends. And considering there are more volumes to come, I imagine the killing games aren’t truly over with either. (I’m not sure how that will work exactly, but I guess I only have to wait a few months to find out.)
Before anyone mentions this – part of the reason why the anime contained considerably more content than the light novel is that there were two versions of this book released in Japan – the original version published under Kono Light Novel ga Sugoi! Bunko (which is what Yen Press has licensed), and a later version published under a nameless light novel label, with extra material – most notably an extra short story. There’s also another volume later in the series (volume 10) which covers roughly the same period as this first volume.
I don’t own either of these volumes so I don’t know how much of the anime’s extra content came from them and how much was anime original, but I would assume at least some of it falls into the former category.
I can’t help but feel sorry for Tama in this series. Even if sometimes only by accident, she was often the real heroine of the series. The logic behind Swim Swim killing her was right (even if Swim Swim didn’t necessarily understand it herself) but that doesn’t make it any less sad…
It’s fun to read out some of Fav’s lines in his super-cheerful voice. Particularly from Chat #5. Fav’s a total bastard, though.
Thanks for sharing this info, Kuuderes Shadow! That’s interesting to hear there are multiple versions of this story. Seems to go along with the author’s afterword, about how it was a particularly difficult story to pin down how things should play out. It has one of those setups where there is a near-infinite number of combinations regarding who kills who, and in what manner.
I’ve been told the anime is a good one, so I’d like to give it a watch this summer to see for myself. Perhaps I can write something up comparing it to the book.
Tama is definitely a character to feel sorry for, and this volume was especially cruel by giving her such a sudden death immediately after she finally achieved something significant. Swim meanwhile was a character who caught me off-guard, as I’m sure was intended by the reveal of her real age. I have to wonder if there is something out there that explains her personality a bit.
Fav was an amusing character to me. I always liked how nonchalant he was about everything. In some strange way, he’s a bit relatable in how he’s simply this random worker who doesn’t care about his job and thinks everything about it is just stupid.
It’s not alternative timelines and stuff like that – 16人ã®æ—¥å¸¸ contains 5 short stories about events that happen in the novel but aren’t shown in the original book – at least a couple of which are definitely in the anime (eg. one covers what actually happened immediately following the end of chapter 3), while the other version of volume 1 is (from what I’ve read) the exact same story, except with extra illustrations, a short story about Snow White, and a short manga about Nemurin.
I’m not going to say more than that on the matter as I don’t want to get into spoiler territory.
Will the light novel continue were the anime left off?