Review: Missing — Spirited Away

(art by Shin Midorikawa)

(art by Shin Midorikawa)

For general information on this series: Missing entry

This review is for the first volume of Missing by Gakuto Coda. The English edition was released by Tokyopop in November 2007. One more volume was eventually released, but the remaining eleven novels were never localized. Note that artwork by Shin Midorikawa was included in the original Japanese edition, but not for the English release.

Vol 1 - Spirited Away

Vol 1 – Spirited Away

Missing is a novel I feel might have been released at a bad time, or perhaps simply wasn’t marketed the best way (or at all). I’ve never heard anyone mention it, let alone discuss its contents–and that may be reasonable, when light novels were not as well-known in the West at the time. And with the live-action cover, I imagine anime/manga fans simply wouldn’t have ever recognized it as something they’d want to pick up. What might have worked better, would be to use a cover similar to the original one (but perhaps designed with spookier colors), and slap on a quote from someone saying “Missing is a LOT like Ghost Hunt!”

I will let that segue into my main impression of this novel: It’s a LOT like Ghost Hunt. And that’s certainly not a bad thing, considering how much I like that series. The story of Missing involves a group of high school students in literature club who get caught up in a mystery surrounding their most unusual member: Kyoichi Utsume, a deathly serious boy who cares little for–well, pretty much everything, save for the occult. One day he randomly brings to school a small waif named Ayame, whom he solemnly dubs his girlfriend… and the next day he and Ayame go missing entirely.

Interestingly, the core of the book’s mystery is all about these two figures–Kyoichi and Ayame–but with them being absent for the vast majority of the story, we instead spend much more time following the much more normal members of the club. The main question posed regarding Ayame is whether or not she is a kami-kakushi, a spirit who kidnaps people and traps them in a horrific spiritual realm–and if so, how to go about actually bringing Utsume back.

Much of the book entails the club members discussing creepy events with each other, and then speaking with certain individuals involved with the occult… who then go to great length about various spirit-related theories. It’s actually all quite interesting (and seems very well-researched), but many readers may find the pages of exposition to feel more like long info-dumps than anything else. It makes for a slower-paced light novel, but the author (and translator) did well to create several engaging layers to a mystery filled with strong prose. I will note though that the book had a strange issue working with transitions… Pretty much every chapter or section would end quite suddenly, which I always found a little bizarre.

Overall Missing is a good read though, and one of Tokyopop’s best-written light novels. I wasn’t able to care too much for most of the characters though (the biggest difference between it and Ghost Hunt in my opinion), and the story itself was fairly underwhelming, despite some clever concepts. That said, it still offers a lot to like for mystery and horror fans, so I will recommend it most strongly for them.

Cho’s Rating: Recommended

4 responses to “Review: Missing — Spirited Away

  1. Wow, I’ve had this on my to-read list for quite some time now, but I didn’t know there was an English release. Pity that it didn’t get as much attention as other licensed light novel series (which isn’t so much to begin with…).
    Also, minor typo: the author’s name is “Gakuto” not “Gakuta”.

    • Thanks, I’ve fixed the typo.
      It’s a shame that Missing (and many other Tokyopop LN series… and manga) were dropped unfinished, but this first volume at least works well as its own self-contained story (and is available dirt-cheap on Amazon). Not sure how much of a chance there is, but perhaps there could be an anime adaptation of the series one day? Mystery horror anime are fairly rare these days unfortunately. =/

      • I really don’t see an anime adaptation happening. The series finished more than 9 years ago, and I believe the light novel series that got an anime adaptation the longest after its completion in recent years was Toaru Hikuushi e no Koiuta, where the anime came 3 years later (and the overarching franchise of that is still ongoing) – indeed the last light novel before that with a longer gap between the final (and in this case only) ending and anime airing was probably Toaru Hikuushi e no Tsuioku, at about 3.5 years (I haven’t checked this, though). Furthermore, the series has been out of print for years and is not available to buy new – I don’t think any LN has ever got an adaptation in that situation.

  2. Pingback: Missing | English Light Novels·

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s