Review: Kieli — Prisoners Bound for Another Planet

Kieli, volume 3

For general information on this series: Kieli entry

This review is for the third volume of Kieli, by Yukako Kabei (with art by Shunsuke Taue). The English edition was released by Yen Press in September 2010, and the remaining six volumes of the series have since been officially localized.

Vol 3 – Prisoners Bound for Another Planet

Kieli, Harvey, and the Corporal have settled in a mining town near the ruins of an old space ship–a vessel that exiled prisoners to the series’ desert planet so many years ago. The setting goes along perfectly with the state of things for our lead characters: a somber and difficult journey has ended, and now a struggle for some semblance of normal living has begun. While Kieli works at a local cafe, Harvey is searching for answers to questions partly resulting from the fallout of volume 2. But how long can any of us readers expect their (relatively) peaceful lives to last?

This volume starts off with a couple vignettes in which our leads deal with some “spirit of the week” diversions. First, Harvey gets caught up in the violent contention of an estranged couple and their sickly daughter (all continuing to linger on as ghosts). Later, Kieli meets a young man (another neighbor, and a struggling author) who is under the spell of a dangerous spirit possessing his typewriter. These side stories are inconsequential, but are nice for giving the characters some breathing room.

The main plot of this volume begins once we learn about the individual Harvey has located and been in contact with: a woman named Beatrix, who is an Undying like him. She turns out to be an interesting character, in that she’s a source of conflict for our two leads, pushing to split them apart — but she’s not a bad person, and the issues she presents are all valid. Harvey is indeed a dangerous person for Kieli to stick around, and in turn Kieli is technically a hindrance for Harvey if he has to worry about her whenever trouble arises (which is all the time in this series). Beatrix also poses the question of how a regular person and an Undying can ever truly understand one another, especially when the Undying have a past as horrific as the War weighing them down. Beatrix too is haunted by her own past (as would be expected for this series), and the author works in a kind of “Joan of Arc tragedy” for her. (It was only a matter of time, right? If I had a dollar for every Joan of Arc reference in Japanese fiction…)

The story ramps up for an action-packed final act when the machinations of a mad scientist type character (secretly conducting occult research in the husk of the abandoned space ship) enters the picture. He is hoping to bring his dead little sister back to life, and an Undying like Harvey could contain the secret solution he needs to make that possible. I kind of expected someone like him to show up at some point in this series, to be honest. Also to be expected, Harvey gets put through the wringer once again, arguably even worse than in the previous two volumes.

In the end though, the status quo for our leads has definitely changed, and it feels like it’ll be a shift that will shake up the formula enough to keep me guessing where things will go from here. So while some aspects of this volume felt a bit too familiar, I did really appreciate the world-building, as well as certain scenes packed with particularly strong dialogue.

Cho’s Rating: Recommended

You can purchase this book online via sites like Amazon (available in paperback or as an ebook) and Book Depository (which offers free worldwide shipping). These are affiliate links, so a small percentage of sales goes toward this site.

4 responses to “Review: Kieli — Prisoners Bound for Another Planet

    • I like how each (rare) time I do find some discussion on the Kieli series, it seems unanimous that the Corporal is considered the best character, ha ha. If only everyone had a radio to talk some sense into them with!

      I like Beatrix as well; she’s amusingly easy to relate to at times for me. She’s also interesting to compare/contrast with Harvey. They are both Undying, but go about their lives quite differently.

  1. It’s a very small thing — but I remember this volume being a huge improvement over how it did the “spirit of the week” thing. During the final act when Harvey reaffirmed his feelings and he even referenced the sickly daughter in the first chapter, I really loved that. Thought it’s pretty cool to go back around and make that connection, lol.

    Also looking at all these pictures again, kinda made me miss short-haired Kieli, lol.

    • Yes, I appreciate any callbacks the series makes to smaller past events. Kabei does a good job using smaller events as stepping stones, placing hints for bigger things to come in future volumes.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s